The original is one click away. Open original ↗
How to find and hire the right second-in-command for your company
Executive overview
Most founders give out senior titles without matching responsibility or compensation — a habit that started with banks in the 90s. A true second-in-command isn't necessarily a COO; the right title depends on the role's scope, metrics, and pay.
The right hire is stage-specific and founder-specific. They fill exactly what you're bad at.
The key insight: your second-in-command is defined by what drains you, not by a job title.
What a real C-level title requires
- Strategic input that shapes company direction — not just execution
- Genuine autonomy: they identify what needs doing without being told
- P&L and budget responsibility
- Compensation that matches the title ($250K–$550K range for a true COO)
- Their own relationships and partners they bring into the company
Why the right hire is stage- and founder-specific
- Cameron Herold was the right COO for 1-800-GOT-JUNK from $2M to $100M — wrong for almost any other company
- Eric Church (the successor COO) would have failed in the early stage but thrived from $100M to $1B
- COO fit depends on industry match, company size, and personal chemistry with the CEO
- Even replacing a frustrating COO produces a new frustrating COO — the job is to coach them, not swap them
How to define what you need
- List everything you're bad at as a founder
- List everything that drains your energy
- List projects you want done but never reach
- List functions that report to you but where you're not competent
- Flip that list — that's the role you're hiring for
- Map your own personality profile (Kolbe, DISC) and look for the complementary counterpart
How to hire
- Define the title to match responsibilities and metrics — not aspirationally
- Set compensation to match the title; don't put a big title on a small role
- Use specialist executive search firms (e.g. Max Hansen / Y Scouts for COO-level hires)
- Share your vivid vision early — strong candidates who don't connect with it will self-select out
More like this — when you're ready for early access.
Join the waitlist for a personal account and content recommendations based on what you're working on.
No spam. Unsubscribe at any time.
You're on the list. We'll be in touch before launch.